CoursesFailure to Communicate
ENGL 2145

Failure to Communicate

The phrase “failure to communicate” became iconic in American English from the 1967 film “Cool Hand Luke,” in which Paul Newman played a convict who refuses to listen or follow orders. The film raised questions about the multiple ways we understand “failure to communicate” and its consequences. Is it sometimes a decision to resist a presumption, a premise, an interpretation, an argument, a directive from authority? Is it at other times simply a mechanical failure?

Instructor(s)
  • Carlin Romano
Semester

Fall 2022

Register
Tuesdays, 7 PM – 10 PM

This course examines “failure to communicate” in a variety of cultural areas, among them literature, romance, politics, theater, law, science, war, and education. We’ll bring literary, philosophical, psychological and historical perspectives to these issues. Materials will include literary fiction (e.g., short stories by Jhumpa Lahiri, Herman Melville, Toni Morrison), drama (e.g., Edward Albee’s “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?”), poetry (e.g., Robert Frost’s “Home Burial”) film (“Cool Hand Luke” among others) TV (e.g., an episode from “House”), and significant nonfiction, journalism and scholarship. We’ll also experiment, trying some role-playing communication exercises with students: a couple breaking up, a U.S. general talking to a Russian general, a novelist trying to explain to an editor why some material shouldn’t be cut, a back-and-forth between a stopped driver and a police officer. Finally, we’ll have to ask whether failure to communicate is always a bad thing, and how to avoid its worst consequences.

Requirements: A 6-page midterm paper, a 15-page final paper, 10 short (up to two paragraphs) ungraded critical comments on assigned reading or viewing over the term, and active participation in class discussion.

Please contact Professor Carlin Romano if you have any questions at cromano@asc.upenn.edu

Related Content

Other Courses of Interest

WRIT 0021/307

Critical Writing: Organizing for Social Justice

Instructor(s)

  • Dilshanie Perera

Semester

Fall 2026

During times that seem politically bleak, you might ask: how is it possible to create lasting social change? What does it mean to organize? What can justice look like in practice? This course examines how change is created incrementally, in the everyday, and in response to structures of oppression, and how it is possible to renew the power of the collective and of the imagination. We will read Kelly Hayes and Mariame Kaba’s Let This Radicalize You: Organizing and the Revolution of Reciprocal Care to examine how organizers enact the hard work of transformative social and political change. Through theoretical, historical, ethnographic, and practical examples, students will gain an understanding of political mobilization and movement building across different contexts. Student research will focus on contemporary movements for justice, articulating their analyses for different audiences through their white paper and op-ed projects.

Learn More
WRIT 0021/302

Critical Writing: Minds in the Wild

Instructor(s)

  • Nora Bradford

Semester

Fall 2026

How smart are you? How smart is your dog? We often measure intelligence by human standards – testing parrots on their ability to name shapes or timing dogs while they solve puzzles. Through this course, we’ll flip the script and put ourselves in animals’ shoes. We’ll mainly read Ed Yong’s recent book examining what various animals actually take in through their senses. Students may focus their research on the sensing, cognition, or communication of a specific species, or on the adoption of new tools, like AI, for improving our understanding of animals. Writing assignments will focus on articulating the recent findings, as well as gaps, within animal intelligence research.

Learn More